Nina Whitney and Cara Jo Roberts Murder: How Did They Die? Who Killed Them?

Nina Whitney and Cara Jo Roberts Murder: How Did They Die? Who Killed Them? Well, this is the question that is causing people’s minds to whirl these days. So, let’s delve a little deeper into this individual’s life to learn more about who he is and how he died. As a result, when 75-year-old Nina Whitney was found stabbed to death in her Kansas City, Missouri, home, investigators assumed she knew the killer.

When DNA from Nina’s murder scene matched a sample extracted from the unrelated murder of Cara Jo Roberts, they quickly determined they were dealing with a serial killer. ‘Unusual Suspects: Deadly Intent A Taste for Blood,’ a documentary on Investigation Discovery, analyses the murders and explains how the perpetrator was apprehended after a startling insight. Let’s delve in and see where the murderer is right now, shall we?

Nina Whitney and Cara Jo Roberts Murder: How Did Nina Whitney and Cara Jo Roberts Die?

Cara Jo Roberts was a mother of two and a well-known figure in her neighborhood. She lived in Harrisonville, Missouri, where she was regarded as a free-spirited and down-to-earth woman by her neighbors. Cara was very devoted to her family, and she always strived to put her children first. Everyone was constantly greeted with a smile by the friendly attitude. Cara’s family and friends still miss her tremendously. Nina Whitney, a 75-year-old mother, on the other hand, was renowned as a generous and compassionate person.

Nina lived alone in Kansas City, Missouri, and was cared for by her daughter, despite having strong relations with her family. Her daughter, in fact, discovered her mother’s body after not hearing from her for a long period. Cara Roberts was killed in her house on November 5, 2008, when an assailant stormed in and shot her. Despite the fact that the police were called in right away, they were unable to locate a suspect or person of interest. Cara’s death was caused by bullet wounds. According to the autopsy report, however, the victim had been sexually molested prior to her murder. Furthermore, despite the fact that there was no indication of a forced entry at the crime site, the police discovered her bathtub running.

Unfortunately, Cara’s murder went undetected for two years, while Nina Whitney was discovered dead in her Kansas City home on October 29, 2010. Nina’s daughter initially thought she had a heart attack, but authorities soon discovered she had been stabbed to death. Nina’s top was even pushed up to her breasts, indicating that she had been sexually abused, according to the medical examiner. Nina’s murder scene, surprisingly, showed no traces of forced entry, and investigators discovered a twisted and bloodied knife, which appeared to be the murder weapon, alongside an overflowing bathtub.

Nina Whitney and Cara Jo Roberts Murder: Who Killed Nina Whitney and Cara Jo Roberts?

Unfortunately, the police were unable to find a suspect for Cara’s murder even after two years of inquiry, and the case remains unresolved. Authorities struggled to come up with a suspect list when investigating Nina’s murder because there were no eyewitnesses, and the crime scene provided few leads. Despite the fact that Nina’s phone was tracked to a man, he claimed to have picked it up on the side of the road and had a solid alibi to defend his innocence.

Nonetheless, the police knew that the phone had been dropped, and after several interviews, they were able to create a composite portrait of a man who was acting abnormally around Nina’s house on the day of the murder. Despite the fact that the sketch did not lead the authorities to a suspect, forensic investigations revealed that the foreign DNA collected at Nina’s murder site matched that extracted from Cara’s body, implying a possible serial killer. Despite the lack of a link between Cara and Nina, police were back to square one.

Nina’s daughter, Paige, had a stunning insight seven months after the murder and discovered that the man in the sketch was one of her ex-boyfriends, and law enforcement officials were in for a big breakthrough. The suspect was identified as Jeff Moreland, and authorities were able to determine that he was the owner of the same black SUV seen near Nina’s residence on the day of the murder. Jeff insisted on his innocence and refused to offer his DNA sample. Despite this, the show said that he was accused of rape by a lady and that once he was arrested, the police extracted his DNA. The suspect’s DNA matched that of Cara and Nina’s crime scenes, much to everyone’s amazement, and Jeff was arrested and charged with murder.

Where Is Jeff Moreland Now?

Jeff Moreland was charged with the rape and murder of Cara Jo Roberts in 2013 and was found guilty. As a result, he was given a life sentence with an extra 50 years in prison. In 2020, Jeff pled guilty to second-degree murder and armed criminal action in the death of Nina Whitney and was sentenced to 20 years in prison plus a 10-year probationary period. We can fairly conclude that Jeffrey is still behind bars, serving time for his crimes, despite the fact that his present location does not appear in state offender records.

Also Read: Are Brandon and Taylor From Married At First Sight Season 10 Still Together?